Try both in a store and you may notice that the keyboards respond differently. Pressed slowly, the Roland can show a slight step in resistance (its simulated escapement). The Kawai has no escapement simulation. Neither keyboard is wrong. They are simply different, and in the store it is hard to tell which difference should matter to you.

This article sorts out those differences using the manufacturers' published specifications.

What you're actually choosing between

These two pianos sit in the same bracket — which of the two is cheaper depends on the market you buy in — and they share a lot: 88 keys, Bluetooth Audio and MIDI, dual headphone jacks, line out, recording. Beyond that, the specifications differ. The FP-30X has 256-note polyphony, the ES120 192. The Roland offers 56 tones from the panel (321 with the app), the Kawai 25. Speaker output is 22 W on the Roland and 20 W on the Kawai. Weight and keyboard design differ too.

The key feel question — translated into human terms

The Roland FP-30X uses the PHA-4 Standard action with Ivory Feel keytops. Roland states that it simulates escapement: a subtle change in resistance when a key is pressed slowly. On an acoustic piano, that moment corresponds to the hammer being released just before it strikes the string.

The Kawai ES120 uses the Responsive Hammer Compact action with matte keytops. It has no escapement simulation.

Having escapement simulation does not by itself make a keyboard better. Some players prefer a noticeable step, others prefer a keyboard without one. If you play or take lessons on an acoustic piano, try both keyboards yourself: which one feels closer depends on that particular piano, not on the specification.

Rhythms: built into the ES120, through an app on the FP-30X

The ES120 includes 100 built-in rhythm patterns — jazz brushes, bossa nova, waltz, rock, swing. They work without an app: start a rhythm and play your melody over it.

Rhythm accompaniment can add variety to practice, especially when you practise alone. The FP-30X has no built-in rhythms; the instrument itself offers only a metronome. Roland provides accompaniment through Roland Piano App, which supports the FP-30X, so you need a phone or tablet connected to the piano.

The weight difference

Kawai gives the ES120's weight as 12 kg without the music rest (the figure in the spec table) and 12.5 kg with it. Roland publishes a single figure for the FP-30X: 14.8 kg with the music rest. Compared on the same basis, with the music rest, that is 12.5 kg against 14.8 kg. A 2.3 kg difference sounds trivial until you move the instrument between rooms, take it to a friend's place, or put it away in a cupboard. If your piano lives permanently in one spot, this is irrelevant. If you expect to move it, the ES120 is easier to carry on your own.

Sound and settings

The two use different sound engines: SuperNATURAL Piano on the Roland, Harmonic Imaging on the Kawai. The name of the technology does not tell you which one sounds better. Compare how each responds to playing strength and how it sounds with the sustain pedal held down. Long pedalling and layered sounds increase how many notes sound at once; if that goes beyond a model's limit, some notes may be cut off.

The ES120, for its part, has Virtual Technician: settings adjusted through the PianoRemote app, including touch response, key-release sound and damper resonance. These are optional settings; you do not need to change them to start practising. They are useful for a player who knows how they want the instrument to respond.

Who should buy which piano

Buy the Kawai ES120 if you practise mainly at home on your own and move the piano now and then, if you want to play along with rhythms without a phone or app, or if you are returning to the piano and want to adjust how the instrument responds through the app.

Buy the Roland FP-30X if you prefer a keyboard with escapement simulation, or if more panel tones matter to you. Roland offers a dedicated stand and a three-pedal unit for it, and the FP-60X sits above it in the range.

The keyboard and the way you practise should decide this, not the logo.